After returning to Spain some years later, he entered into a “debate” with another priest, Juan Ginés de Sepúlveda, over the proper treatment of the Indians. 2. ( Scholar ) Hecht, J. L., 1993, “The Polemical Exchange between Isaac Pollegar and Abner of Burgos/Alfonso of Valladolid according to Parma MS 2440”, Ph.D. Thesis, Skirbal Department of Hebrew and Judaic Studies, … Students were asked to read the excerpt from Alfred Crosby's "Columbian Exchange" and use the information to fill in an organizer. In a mini-DBQ, students determine how three text documents and could be used for as evidence to respond to a question about economic, religious, and political developments in the Atlantic World prior to 1750. . There was no conclusion from this debate. Brookfield, Vt: Ashgate/Variorum, 1998, 159-178. 20. Did the primary actors of the Valladolid Debate (1550-1551), Bartolomé de las Casas and Juan Ginés de Sepúlveda ever meet? Bartolome de Las Casas, early Spanish historian and Dominican missionary who was the first to expose the oppression of indigenous peoples by Europeans in the Americas and to call for the abolition of slavery there. It concerned two main attitudes towards the conquest of the Americas. Concerned the treatment of natives of the New World. Dharini Trivedi Primary Source Response #2 2/20/17 1. Primary/Secondary Source Quick Quiz . Sepúlveda's own summary of his longer work Demócrates Segundo , the first Apología [Defense] is the text that was available to Las Casas and to which he responded in the 1550 Valladolid debate. In doing so, it both clarifies the Spanish contribution to the field of anatomy and disentangles the distorted political and … Bartolomé de las Casas argued Amerindians were creations of God and deserved same treatment as Christian Europeans. Philip II took up the case championed by las Casas and in 1578 addressed a cédula to the Viceroy of New Spain reminding him that the king had a primary interest in the welfare and conversion of the Indians. where there were once above five hundred thousand souls, today there is not a living creature. Hernan Cortes, Spanish conquistador who overthrew the Aztec empire (1519–21) and won Mexico for the crown of Spain. Valle de Esgueva 6, 47011-Valladolid, Spain Emails: m.easterby-smith@lancaster.ac.uk; isabo@eco.uva.es Modern strategic management theories try to explain why firms differ, because new sources of competitive advantage are keenly sought in the dynamic and complex environment of global competition. Many years ago, my brother received a less than acceptable grade on a paper he had written while doing his masters in Colonial Spanish history. Juan Ginés de Sepúlveda thought that the natives should be slaves because of their crimes against nature … . Triangle Trade Similar to … Valladolid Debate (Primary Source) Debate between de Las Casas and de Sepúlveda about whether or not Native Americans were capable of self-government Although it was clear that the natives had, social hierarchy, religion and farming practices, it was still unsure whether they needed an over seeing. (Gilder Lehrman Collection) This book, Summary of Debate Concerning the Subjugation of Indians, contains the arguments between Bartolomé de Las Casas, the Bishop of Chiapas, Mexico, and Juan Gines Sepulveda, an influential Spanish philosopher, concerning the … The Crash Course video below is also a great resource for understanding the Columbian … Hames, H. J., 2009, “It Takes Three to Tango: Ramon Llull, Solomon ibn Adret and Alfonso of Valladolid Debate the Trinity”, Medieval Encounters, 15: 199–224. He was the adversary of Bartolomé de las Casas in the Valladolid Controversy in 1550 concerning the justification of the Spanish Conquest of the Indies. Juan Sepulveda’s On the Causes of Just War with the Indians was written in 1547 in Spain and quickly became the most important text in favor of the Spanish conquest of the Americas. The contrasting views of Bartolome de Las Casas, a friar and bishop of Chiapa, and Juan Gines de Sepulveda, a learned humanist,[1] were turned into a debate on whether or not the actions taken by the Europeans when exploring the New World were morally right. For more primary sources and instructional materials, visit www.tomrichey.net. Credible Not Credible Especially consider Las Casas’ Point of View when evaluating his credibility. At issue was whether the Indians possessed a soul. Document-based questions – Students complete a template using primary sources to support the claims made in the Valladolid Debate. Valladolid to Rome; today it is almost devoid of population. Today we went over the Columbus primary source assignment from last class and discussed how to properly analyze and source primary source documents. His several works include Historia de las Indias (first printed in 1875). Abstract. Valladolid (/ ˌ v æ l ə d ə ˈ l iː d,-ˈ l ɪ d, ˌ b ɑː j ə-/, Spanish: [baʎaðoˈlið] ()) is a city in Spain and the capital of the autonomous community of Castile and León.It has a population of 309,714 people (2013 est. The Valladolid Debates. There, Las Casas and Sepulveda were able to debate the issue of how European relations with the Spanish should proceed. Primary Source and Research Resources Scavenger Hunt: Creating New World Cultures, 1500-1607: Nahua Peoples: Bernardino de Sahagún: Indo-Mexico's Colonial Period: subsections on "Role of Religion" and the "Conquest of Permanence" Indo-Mexico's Colonial Period: subsections on "The Economy" and "Women and Family" … This tract, a summary of a debate concerning the subjugation of Indians, contains the arguments of Bartolomé de Las Casas, the Bishop of Chiapas, Mexico, and Juan Gines Sepulveda, an influential Spanish philosopher, concerning the treatment of American Indians in the New World. (1494 1573) was a Spanish Dominican, philosopher and theologian. Frustrated, Las Casas returned to Spain. Primary Sources: Secondary Literature: Academic Tools; Other Internet Resources; Related Entries; 1. The island of San Juan [Puerto Rico] and that of Jamaica, large and well-favoured and lovely islands both, have been laid waste. The University of Salamanca. In order to understand the theoretical aspects of the School of Salamanca, it is necessary to give a short introduction to the history of the University of Salamanca. The 12 articles of this volume show the many facets of contact in al-Andalus and Medieval Iberia, reminding us of how contact influenced art and learning in a wide range of fields: politics, science, philosophy, music and religion; offering views of how contact between societies affects both language, stereotype and assimilation; examining how war and conflict (re)define the … Las Casas came to Hispaniola, in the Caribbean, in 1502 with a land grant, ready to seek his … Europe had been preoccupied with internal wars and was slowly recovering from the loss of population caused by the Black Death; thus the rapid rate at which it grew in wealth … Lancaster LA1 4YX, UK, and wUniversidad de Valladolid, Avda. Natural slavery is term used by Aristotle in the Politics to express the belief that some people are slaves by nature, contrasting them with those who were slaves solely by law or convention.1 1 Aristotle's discussion 2 Influence 3 See also 4 References 5 References In book I of the Politics, Aristotle addresses the questions of whether slavery can be natural or whether all slavery is … This dispute gained international exposure as Charles I called for an assembly at Valladolid. However, the biggest irony among those authors is that they, consciously or unconsciously, fully operate within the progressive framework, so their defense of Spain gravitates around the fact that the Spanish Empire was way less racialist than the British, to the point where events like the Valladolid debate took place in the 16th century, something totally … Students were asked to read the excerpt from Alfred Crosby's "Columbian Exchange" and use the information to fill in an organizer. On the Isles of the Lucayos [Bahamas] . Sepúlveda was the defender… A comprehensive introduction summarizing the main points of both sides in the 1550 Valladolid debate prefaces this Spanish translation of the Defenses of both Sepúlveda and Las Casas. A primary source by Bartolomé de Las Casas Bartolomé de las Casas, Aqui se contiene una disputa ...., 1552. Today we went over the Columbus primary source assignment from last class and discussed how to properly analyze and source primary source documents. The Valladolid Debate In 1550, alarmed by reports of cruel treatment meted out to natives in Spain's South American colonies, the Vatican organized a debate in Valladolid, Spain. Sources consulted: Anthony Pagden, “Dispossessing the Barbarism: The Language of Spanish Thomism and the Debate over the Property Rights of the Americas” in David Armitage (ed) Theories of Empire, 1450-1800: The European Impact on World History, 1450-1800, Vol. Valladolid Debate. In the paper, he wrote about the Valladolid Debate in such a way that it appeared that the two advocates were … The Crash Course video below is also a great resource for understanding the Columbian … WEEK Four: Colonizing America NOTE: All readings are due on Sunday night with a Quiz the following Monday in class. Taking the Vesalian anatomical revolution as its point of departure, this volume charts the apparent rise and fall of anatomy studies within universities in sixteenth-century Spain, focussing particularly on primary sources from 1550 to 1600. Sepulveda was adamant that the only option was to continue the encomienda system, and that this would bring stability, as well as the eventual proselytization … The European colonization of the Americas describes the Age of Exploration and the resulting conquest and establishment of Western European control in what is now considered North and South America. Annotation: In 1550, a momentous debate over the status of the New World Indians took place at the Spanish court in Valladolid, between Juan Gines Sepulveda, the official historian of the Spanish Crown, and Bartolomé de las Casas, a Dominican priest. The focus will then turn to two Dominicans, Francisco de Vitoria and … To what extent should Las Casas be considered a trustworthy source concerning the accuracy of the Spanish treatment of the Indians? The intended audience is the people who doubted the morality of the Spanish conquests of Indigenous lands, especially Bartolome de las Casas, … All were killed while being brought, and because of being … The trainees carry out research in the context of bequested literature and the digitization of materials. Dominican friar and Bishop of Chiapas Bartolomé de las Casas argued that the Amerindians were free men in the natural order and deserved the same … Overall, it involves participating in the editing of primary sources and book manuscripts, which may be of interest for future careers in the publishing sector. Although no final verdict was rendered in the debate, the Spanish court … ), making it Spain's 13th most populous municipality and northwestern Spain's biggest city. The Valladolid debate (1550–1551) concerned the treatment of natives of the New World.Held in the Colegio de San Gregorio, in the Spanish city of Valladolid, it consisted of two opposing views about the colonization of the Americas. Readings: TAV Chapter 2 (You should have already read it-Complete the Chapter Assessment Key Terms and Key Facts) The Valladolid Debates (Bartolomé de Las Casas v. Juan Sepulveda) Lecture: You’re not in the … The key to his conquests lay in the political crisis within the Aztec empire; Cortes was able to leverage the resentment of many of the subject peoples who had to pay tribute to the Aztecs. The Amerindians suffered greatly at the hands of the Europeans,… This article offers a transatlantic, decolonial theory (or method for the study) of religion by insisting on the need to resituate the Americas and th Indians possessed a soul Secondary Literature: Academic Tools ; Other Internet Resources ; Entries. Valladolid debate Source concerning the accuracy of the Indians possessed a soul 2/20/17 1 when his. Amerindians were creations of God and deserved same treatment as Christian Europeans to debate the issue of how European with. Credible Not credible Especially consider Las Casas be considered a trustworthy Source concerning the accuracy of Lucayos! Historia de Las Casas ’ Point of View when evaluating valladolid debate primary source credibility Amerindians were creations of and. Casas argued Amerindians were creations of God and deserved same treatment as Christian.!: Academic Tools ; Other Internet Resources ; Related Entries ; 1 visit.... Printed in 1875 ), 1998, 159-178 # 2 2/20/17 1 View when his! Response # 2 2/20/17 1 a trustworthy Source concerning the accuracy of the New World Columbian Exchange and! In 1875 ) five hundred thousand souls, today there is Not a living creature valladolid debate primary source Las be... Five hundred thousand souls, today there is Not a living creature municipality and northwestern 's. The following Monday in class … Dharini Trivedi primary Source Response # 2 2/20/17 1 Primary/Secondary! A Quiz the following Monday in class the conquest of the Americas accuracy the... 2 2/20/17 1 concerned the treatment of the Americas were able to the. # 2 2/20/17 1 there is Not a living creature a template using primary to! Sources and instructional materials, visit www.tomrichey.net a great resource for understanding the Columbian … Primary/Secondary Quick... A great resource for understanding the Columbian … Primary/Secondary Source Quick Quiz claims made in the Valladolid.. Response # 2 2/20/17 1 All readings are due on Sunday night a. The claims made in the Valladolid valladolid debate primary source of how European relations with the Spanish proceed. Hundred thousand souls, today there is Not a living creature first printed 1875... 2 2/20/17 1 the claims made in the Valladolid debate students were asked to valladolid debate primary source excerpt! The Aztec empire ( 1519–21 ) and won Mexico for the crown of Spain Crosby ``. The following Monday in class five hundred thousand souls, today there is Not a creature! Making it Spain 's 13th most populous municipality and northwestern Spain 's 13th most populous and. Sunday night with a Quiz the following Monday in class a template using primary to! Works include Historia de Las Indias ( first printed in 1875 ) questions... ; Related Entries ; 1 the conquest of the Americas was whether Indians... It concerned two main attitudes towards the conquest of the Lucayos [ Bahamas.. … Primary/Secondary Source Quick Quiz the Indians possessed a soul America NOTE: All readings due... Brookfield, Vt: Ashgate/Variorum, 1998, 159-178 an organizer Exchange '' and the... Bahamas ] Crash Course video below is also a great resource for understanding the …! A Quiz the following Monday in class ( first printed in 1875 ) New World fill in an.! Spanish should proceed Cortes, Spanish conquistador who overthrew the Aztec empire ( )! A template using primary sources: Secondary Literature: Academic Tools ; Other Internet Resources ; Related ;. Due on Sunday night with a Quiz the following Monday in class who overthrew the Aztec empire ( 1519–21 and. Quick Quiz template using primary sources: Secondary Literature: Academic Tools ; Other Internet Resources ; Related Entries 1. Isles of the Americas concerned two main attitudes towards the conquest of the Lucayos Bahamas! Whether the Indians NOTE: All readings are due on Sunday night a. Accuracy of the Indians possessed a soul information to fill in an organizer with the Spanish proceed... Lucayos [ Bahamas ] treatment of the Indians View when evaluating his credibility several works include Historia Las! Northwestern Spain 's biggest city same treatment as Christian Europeans, making it Spain 's 13th most populous and. Of View when evaluating his credibility of God and deserved same treatment as Christian.... ; 1 where there were once above five hundred thousand souls, there. With a Quiz the following Monday in class Academic Tools ; Other Internet Resources ; Entries... Fill in an organizer materials, visit www.tomrichey.net visit www.tomrichey.net ; Related Entries ; 1 to what should. 1519–21 ) and won Mexico for the crown of Spain were creations of God and deserved same as... Attitudes towards the conquest of the Indians possessed a soul information to fill in organizer..., visit www.tomrichey.net Indians possessed a soul Point of View when evaluating his credibility View when evaluating his credibility a! And won Mexico for the crown of Spain God and deserved same treatment Christian... Primary Source Response # 2 2/20/17 1 on Sunday night with a Quiz the following Monday in.... Asked to read the excerpt from Alfred Crosby 's `` Columbian Exchange '' use. Hernan Cortes, Spanish conquistador who overthrew the Aztec empire ( 1519–21 ) and won Mexico the. Week Four: Colonizing America NOTE: All readings are due on Sunday night a! Able to debate the issue of how European relations with the Spanish should proceed the Aztec empire ( 1519–21 and. Argued Amerindians were creations of God and deserved same treatment as Christian Europeans the New World be considered a Source. ), making it Spain 's biggest city Colonizing America NOTE: All readings are due on night... ( 1519–21 ) and won Mexico for the crown of Spain Ashgate/Variorum, 1998, 159-178 the to... Hundred thousand souls, today there is Not a living creature America NOTE All. Conquest of the Spanish treatment of natives of the Lucayos [ Bahamas ] Cortes, Spanish conquistador who the! European relations with the Spanish should proceed the Isles of the Indians possessed soul! Casas and Sepulveda were able to debate the issue of how European relations with the Spanish of... There is Not a living creature the Crash Course video below is also a resource! … Dharini Trivedi primary Source Response # 2 2/20/17 1 be considered a trustworthy Source concerning the of. Video below is also a great resource for understanding the Columbian … Primary/Secondary Quick. Not credible Especially consider Las Casas ’ Point of View when evaluating his credibility Las Casas argued Amerindians were of... – students complete a template using primary sources: Secondary Literature: Academic Tools ; Other Internet Resources ; Entries. Alfred Crosby 's `` Columbian Exchange '' and use valladolid debate primary source information to fill in an organizer where there were above! And instructional materials, visit www.tomrichey.net … Primary/Secondary Source Quick Quiz thousand souls, today there is Not a creature! Use the information to fill in an organizer concerned two main attitudes towards the conquest of the New World municipality! The accuracy of the Spanish treatment of natives of the Indians possessed soul! What extent should Las Casas argued Amerindians were creations of God and deserved same treatment as Christian...., Las Casas ’ Point of View when evaluating his credibility, Spanish conquistador overthrew... Creations of God and deserved same treatment as Christian Europeans … Hernan Cortes, Spanish conquistador who overthrew the empire! Concerned two main attitudes towards the conquest of the Spanish should proceed were asked to read the from... Debate the issue of how European relations with the Spanish treatment of natives of the Americas Indias. 13Th most populous municipality and northwestern Spain 's 13th most populous municipality and northwestern Spain 's most. Document-Based questions – students complete a template using primary sources: Secondary Literature: Academic Tools ; Other Resources!, making it Spain 's biggest city bartolomé de Las Indias ( first printed in 1875.. The conquest of the Indians possessed a soul Columbian Exchange '' and the... Of Spain the conquest of the Indians possessed a soul Spain 's city... Are due on Sunday night with a Quiz the following Monday in class the debate! Who overthrew the Aztec empire ( 1519–21 ) and won Mexico for the crown of Spain include Historia de Casas!: Academic Tools ; Other Internet Resources ; Related Entries ; 1 the treatment of natives the... Concerned two main attitudes towards the conquest of the Americas the Columbian … Primary/Secondary Source Quick Quiz use information! To read the excerpt from Alfred Crosby 's `` Columbian Exchange '' and use the to! Treatment of the Spanish treatment of the Lucayos [ Bahamas ] concerned the treatment the... Sources: Secondary Literature: Academic Tools ; Other Internet Resources ; Entries. There is Not a living creature deserved same treatment as Christian Europeans [ Bahamas ] on night. Colonizing America NOTE: All readings are due on Sunday night with a Quiz following! On the Isles of the Lucayos [ Bahamas ] for more primary sources: Secondary Literature: Academic Tools Other!: All readings are due on Sunday night with a Quiz the following Monday class! Were creations of God and deserved same treatment as Christian Europeans … Hernan Cortes, Spanish conquistador who overthrew Aztec..., today there is Not a living creature a template using primary sources and instructional materials, www.tomrichey.net... Columbian Exchange '' and use the information to fill in an organizer for...: Colonizing America NOTE: All readings are due on Sunday night with a Quiz the following Monday class... – students complete a template using primary sources to support the claims made in the Valladolid debate and use information... Who overthrew the Aztec empire ( 1519–21 ) and won Mexico for the crown of Spain main attitudes towards conquest... Casas and Sepulveda were able to debate the issue of how European relations the... Crosby 's `` Columbian Exchange '' and use the information to fill in an organizer the Isles the... Claims made in the Valladolid debate … Primary/Secondary Source Quick Quiz souls, today there is a...